• Pl chevron_right

      Jussi Pakkanen: Welcome to Soviet Union 2.0, comrade

      news.movim.eu / PlanetGnome • 18:21 • 5 minutes

    I have a former coworker who was born in the Soviet Union at a very specific time in history. He was just old enough to see the system from the inside and grasp how it works (or, more specifically, did not work) but young enough that it did not consume him. He got out fairly quickly after the collapse and is nowadays doing computer related work in "the west", as it were. Having seen both sides of the world order he had quite an interesting view on why the Soviet Union eventually crashed and how it ties to modern companies.

    Let's assume that you are working in the Soviet Union in a car factory. Your job is to be responsible for all things needed to attach the wheels to the body of the car. In practice this means taking parts from subcontractors (typically other divisions of the same factory) such as break pads and lines, the actual wheels, and all other things and put them together so that the car can roll forward. Seems reasonable enough, right?

    In practice it turns out that all parts you get are actually garbage. The wheels are not properly balanced. The inner tube might have a hole in it or be completely missing. The metal in brake pads has been silently changed to a cheaper one removing 50-70% of braking power. The brake lines are too short for installation. To make them work you'd need to cut holes in the car's superstructure. Your screws are too soft to properly function, but fortunately so are your wrenches. The downside is that after tightening one wheel all your tools are shaped like a banana. And so on and so on.

    Should you find yourself in such a situation, what should you do about it? In theory the parts you are given are not up to spec. So you could file a complaint about it. But you really can't, because then the problem would be you. You would need to do the extra work of getting the people providing you parts to fix their process (which you can't do). You would need to file the paper work. Your name would be on every one of them. When higher ups get reprimanded for cars not getting finished fast enough to reach the requirements of the current five year plan, they are going to come looking for a scapegoat. You made a ruckus. You stopped the pipeline. You are the problem. You get punished.

    But it gets worse. Not only are the people below you not caring and producing garbage work, so are the people above you. At every part of the chain nobody gives a shit, they just take things from below, fiddle with them a bit and then shove them upwards and hope that when things eventually fail, you can deflect the blame on to someone else. If you wish to survive, that is what you must do also. This, according to my coworker, was what eventually brought down the Soviet Union. When all organizational layers of an entire nation gets filled with garbage in – garbage out shovelers, the system loses its capability to function, becomes a zombie, wanders on aimlessly and eventually dies.

    He claims to have witnessed aspects of this appearing in the organizational chains of several software companies and that he has tried to warn them about the bad direction things are heading. Usually to deaf ears.

    But what about today?

    All of that happened years ago. The question is whether any of it still matters in this, our Shining New Era of AI. It most definitely does, more than ever.

    Any organization can tolerate a small fraction of employees that don't particularly care about "the job" and are just hanging around putting in the minimal amount of effort they need to to still remain employed. That is just how large organizations work. The problem is ratio, and this is where AI comes in.

    One of the main non-technical changes AI has brought about seems to be the wholesale conversion of formerly competent and caring people into garbage in – garbage out shovelers. We see them all around us every day. Like the people who handle all emails sent to them by copypasting the entire email thread to a chatbot, asking "what should I reply to this" and then copypasting the entire thing (including the prompt) back as their reply. Or software developers who used to be smart, knowledgeable and competent but suddenly resemble Alzheimer's patients who reply to merge review questions such as "why did you do this thing here" with "I don't know, Claude told me to" and then merge their code without fixing any of the issues raised.

    All of this is exacerbated by all the recent layoffs in the tech sector. No doubt this has been used to rid the company of those pesky troublemakers who dare point out flaws in The Perfect New System. Those who know their history might remember that this was the preferred tactic of Stalin (though, granted, his methods were more extreme). As firing people saves money immediately and only causes problems with a delay, this is seen as a good thing and managers doing it get rewarded.

    And this is where we are today. Many formerly good organizations have become or are on their way to becoming lumbering hulks that can no longer properly function and will eventually collapse under the weight of their own incompetence. You can already feel this with the recent outages of Microsoft cloud and other services. Things that should have worked just breaking down randomly without anyone really knowing why was an every day occurrence in the Soviet Union. People just shrugged it off as an unavoidable fact of life. That is the direction we are heading.

    The last laugh of Lenin

    The latter half of the 20th century was a battle between communism and capitalism. The latter won and having its world view validated went on to an even more extreme end of ultra-capitalism. The ultimate irony is that eventually it reached the exact same end state as communism: an absolute unwavering ideological religion. Which is made all the more amusing by the fact that both of these movements were meant to be fully atheistic.

    In communism the country was filled with party leaders who were vocal that communism would lead to "the workers' paradise" which was "within our grasp just over the horizon", we just have to give it some time. The average person, on the other hand, did not believe a word of this nonsense, just pretended to care to get along with their life.

    I communism 2.0 we instead have CEOs claiming that AI leads to "freeing humanity from the shackles of work" and that "the cure for cancer is just over the horizon", we just have to give them infinite amounts of money first. The average person does not believe a word of this nonsense, just pretend to care to get along with their life.

    At least the Soviet Union had the banging Red Army Choir. All noises the techbro CEOs seem to be capable of producing seem to consist of whingy stuttering and vocal fry.